Food

Coffee: why the same beans can taste so different

· 5 min read
Tutti, Italian Vibe Cafe
Photo: Tutti, Italian Vibe Cafe

You have coffee in two cafés, one after the other. Beans of the same origin, brewed the same way — and they taste as different as two separate drinks. It isn't down to some vague notion of "barista skill". Between the bean and your cup there are a few specific variables, and each one shifts the flavour in a predictable direction.

Specialty coffee is more than a marketing label

On a menu, "specialty" sounds like marketing, but it stands for something you can measure.

According to the Specialty Coffee Association, specialty-grade coffee is coffee that scores 80 points or more out of 100 on the standard cupping form. It must also meet a strict limit on defects — no more than five per 350 grams of green beans — and be selectively hand-picked, so that only ripe cherries are harvested rather than everything on the branch. Under the broader definition, its origin must also be traceable.

Points are awarded for a clean, sweet cup, a balanced body and balanced acidity. In other words, the brightness or slight sourness of good coffee isn't a flaw or a sign that something has gone off; it's a quality that is scored in its own right.

One side effect of these requirements is that robusta has traditionally been almost absent from the specialty segment: its bitterness and high caffeine content don't fit the framework. So "100 % arabica" on a bag doesn't guarantee high quality — it only means the coffee can be assessed on this scale at all.

Roasting changes the chemistry, not just the colour

The biggest differences in flavour are created not in the café but at the roastery — and the mechanism is quite literally chemical.

Coffee beans contain trigonelline, an alkaloid that starts to break down at 160 °C. Roasting goes hotter, up to around 200 °C, and more than half of the trigonelline is lost in the process. But it doesn't simply disappear: its breakdown produces the aroma compounds we perceive as sweet, caramel and earthy notes.

The second pattern is this: light and medium roasts contain the highest concentration of volatile aroma compounds. A dark roast burns some of them off, leaving pronounced bitterness and a toasty character.

That explains why the same variety can taste like two different coffees in two different cafés. If one uses a light roast and the other a dark one, you're drinking different sets of compounds — and neither is "more correct". It's a choice of character, not of quality.

The practical takeaway: if you enjoy fruity or floral notes, look for light and medium roasts. If you prefer the body and bitterness that suit an espresso with milk, a darker roast works better — and that's not a compromise.

What to look for on the menu

Three details set apart a café that takes its coffee seriously from one where coffee is simply on the menu.

The origin is named. Not just "arabica" but the country and region, sometimes even the farm. This isn't snobbery: altitude and region shape the flavour profile just as consistently as roasting does.

The roast level is stated, or at least the flavour profile is described — "citrusy acidity", "dark chocolate bitterness". That lets you choose rather than guess.

There's a roast date, not just a best-before date. The roast date tells you how fresh the coffee is; the best-before date only tells you it's safe to drink.

If none of the three is there, the coffee is probably decent and consistent from day to day — which is a perfectly good choice too, just a different one.

Milk: three drinks from the same base

The difference between a cappuccino, a flat white and a latte isn't the size of the cup but the amount and texture of the milk foam. All three share the same base; what changes is the ratio and how fine the bubbles are.

In practice, if a flat white tastes "right" in one place and not in another, the reason is almost always the milk rather than the coffee. Overheated milk spoils a drink more than mediocre beans do: the proteins change and a cooked taste appears that nothing can mask.

So when you order coffee with milk, you're really judging how well the café handles milk. To judge the beans themselves, order your coffee black — in a new place, it's worth doing at least once.

And here is why all of this matters in Lviv in particular: the city catalogue lists at least fifty coffee shops, yet only six have their own profile describing their equipment and beans. There are plenty of places, but almost no information about what machines they use or what they roast — so the only way to find out is still the same: ask at the counter.

Where to try it

Lviv's coffee culture isn't limited to coffee shops in the strict sense. Some of the best coffee experiences can be found in pastry shops, where coffee is paired with desserts made to go with it: the Ionov Pastry Pharmacy, Veronica Restaurant & Confectionery and Moment.

If you're looking for somewhere to settle in with a laptop or a book, that's a different set of criteria, and it has nothing to do with the beans: power sockets, lighting, noise, and whether you'll be asked to give up your table. Tutti and Zustrich Cafe Bar fall into this category.

For the full choice, see coffee shops and cafés in Lviv. If you want your coffee in the morning with breakfast, there's a separate selection of places that serve breakfast, where the same coffee usually comes with a meal rather than on its own.

One question worth asking

"Which beans are you using for espresso today?" The answer is the quickest test there is. If the barista names the origin and describes the profile, you're in a place where the coffee has been chosen with care. If the answer is "just the usual", that's useful too: you can simply order what you normally drink and not expect any surprises.

Neither answer is a bad one. The only real disappointment is leaving a café thinking "the coffee here tastes odd" without ever learning that it was a light roast from Ethiopia — and that it seemed odd for precisely the qualities people value it for.

Places from the article

Related selections

Read also

Magazine sections